Europeanhhm

Remote health and Telemedicine: Hope for the Future

Rudrajit Paul, Consultant Physician, Ruby General Hospital

Meera Suresh, Associate Professor, Department of Homeopathy, Lincoln University College

The digitalization of all spheres of life had begun in earnest when the Covid-19 pandemic catapulted the health sector into digital age.  Telemedicine can bridge the gap between health systems and people in remote areas with limited resources. Cost might be a constraint for LMICs, nevertheless, the benefits are multiple.

Introduction:

As of 2021, more than 40% of the world population are living in rural areas1. Of them, the majority (~80%) belong to the low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) of South and East Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa1. Although rural domicile is not the sole determinant of the remoteness of healthcare, but rural areas in these countries often lack proper healthcare facilities, transport facilities and diagnostic or therapeutic services. For example, Darjeeling, a hilly town of almost 170,000 people in West Bengal, India got its first and only MRI facility only in 20172. Thus, compared to urban infrastructure, these areas may be still considered “remote” from availability and access point of view. 

The Covid-19 pandemic has made the shortcomings in global health system painfully clear. One of the main shortcomings that has been accentuated in recent times is the lack of coverage in remote areas. For example, Arunachal Pradesh, a remote hilly state of north-East India with an area of 83700 sq. km, has only about 1000 registered doctors3. While overcoming these shortcomings physically (that is, suddenly increasing the number of specialists) will remain a challenge in the near future, new technologies are offering opportunities for alternative ways to provide healthcare in these locations. Telemedicine, which was considered just a promising field earlier, has become mainstream post-Covid and is a means of ensuring universal healthcare. 

Healthcare in Remote places: Present scenario

The Alma-Ata declaration of 1978, establishing the need for universal healthcare, was further affirmed in 2019 when the 83-point “Universal Health Coverage” pledge was taken by UN member states4. However, all countries have realized the fact that although such goals can easily be fulfilled in well-equipped urban centres, the remote areas still remain a challenge. Let’s look at a few examples.

Very recently, a family in a village in North Bengal were forced to take their infant twins to a hospital 200 kilometres away when local treatment facilities were deemed inadequate5. Last year in Sitamahri, Bihar a pregnant woman gave birth on the roadside while being referred to higher centre6. In Liberia, the overall number of health workers, including doctors, have remained very low post civil war and this was one of the reasons why the country fared so badly during the Ebola epidemic7. In many villages in remote mountains of Nepal, the health centres often lack basic essential drugs and this leads to frequent deaths from preventable causes like diarrhoea8

So, although overall health statistics in countries have improved a lot, the situation in the remote areas often remains abysmal. Thus, the current health system is inadequate in addressing these challenges and newer technology is needed. 

Telemedicine:

The World Health Organization (WHO) has defined telemedicine as9

Telehealth is revolutionizing the delivery of healthcare services, particularly in situations where distance plays a critical role. This innovative approach utilizes information and communication technologies to enable healthcare professionals to exchange valid and timely information for the purposes of diagnosis, treatment, and disease prevention. By harnessing the power of telecommunication, telehealth aims to advance the health of individuals and communities alike.

According to the WHO, there are three basic components of telemedicine9

  • Asynchronous digital health care (where information is submitted to the system and is responded later by a health worker) e.g., X ray of a patient is sent to radiologist online for reporting. 
  • Synchronous/real-time care (where the patient interacts with the doctor via audio or video or messaging service in real time) e.g., the ISRO project of linking remote south Indian villages with urban super specialty hospitals for online OPD consultation (GRAMSAT).10
  • Telemonitoring (patients’ parameters are monitored remotely) e.g., the e-ICU facility started in India during Covid pandemic.

The patterns of use of telemedicine can be divided into four main types9

  1. Teleconsultation (the commonest one, where the patient directly seeks consultation of doctor through synchronous or asynchronous means).
  2. Self-help (where the patient seeks help or further information via android applications or websites) e.g. the UCLA has made the Mindful app which is free to use and can help reduce stress.11
  3. Tele-expertise (where healthcare workers can seek opinion of experts) e.g. the SAARC Telemedicine project started by the Government of India to help neighbouring countries get specialist medical advice.12
  4. Tele-triage (quick decision on treatment plan in emergencies) e.g. triage system used during Covid pandemic in some hospitals. It was later seen that this system reduced doctors’ workload, exposure to infectious agents, also improved patient satisfaction, reduced waiting time and consequently overall better health outcomes.13

Acute vs. Chronic care:

Telemedicine, when integrated into existing health system, can be effective both for acute and chronic medical care. 

Acute:
One important example of this is the e-ICU system (Fig. 1) 
Figure 1: Theoretical model for the e-ICU system (as depicted by Rathod et al14)


 
As can be seen in this framework, multiple ICU patient data are collected from camera, sensors, infusion pumps etc and sent to a central server, from where the data is sent to the concerned intensivist. The advantages of this system are standardization of care across multiple ICUs, inclusion of multiple professionals in the care pathway and enabling round the clock care. Also, this system reduces personnel movement in and out of the ICU, thereby reducing the risk of infections both for patient and staff. Disadvantages of the system include the need for initial large-scale investment in technology which may be difficult for LMICs, the possibility of power cuts in remote areas which may wipe out the data and finally, the chance of data leakage14. Also, the intensivists need to be technically adept for the system to function effectively. 

Another acute medicine setting where telemedicine has been effective is burn care15. Furthermore, Taiwan, has shown that the use of telemedicine in acute care can reduce the need of patient transport, especially of air ambulance16. Thus, for LMICs, telemedicine is a means of reducing healthcare costs too. 

Chronic care

The value of telemedicine in chronic care is well established. The age-old model of recurrent hospital visits for refilling prescriptions and/or routine physical examination is slowly being phased out as it’s becoming clear that most of the OPD activities can be conducted online. Even the OPD visits in a busy hospital are time-constrained and often fail to address the concerns of the patient fully. This is where telemedicine can be effective.

Meta-analyses have shown that telemedicine is equivalent to in-person visits for numerous chronic conditions17. In conditions like hypertension and dyslipidemia, non-adherence is a massive problem18. Telemedicine can help in better medicine reconciliation, to have in-depth discussions with the patient which can improve health literacy19 ultimately leading to better adherence. It has been also noted that in hypertension, telemedicine sessions often encourage the patient for self-monitoring, which leads to better blood pressure control19. Finally, in countries like India where most people are employed in unorganized sectors like construction business, single hospital visit, even at a government facility wherein all treatments are free, is still a massive financial burden for many patients. A day spent in hospital means incurring the costs of two-way transport for patient and accompanying person(s) as well as loss of daily wages for all concerned. Telemedicine can help people avoid this financial loss. 

Initial planning for Telemedicine:

However, before telemedicine can be effectively implemented in LMICs, there is need of meticulous planning as pointed out by the WHO (figure 2). 

Figure 2: Steps of planning for Telemedicine (WHO: Consolidated telemedicine implementation guide, 2022) 


 
According to this framework, there are the following four steps of planning:

  1. Step 1: First the proper team must be formed including digital health administrators, digital policy makers, telemedicine regulatory bodies, software developers and online customer support call centres, among others. 
  2. Step 2: All health programs are not amenable to telemedicine. So, the initial priorities must be set. Also, sometimes only those segments of a program, where there are bottlenecks can be targeted for improvement via telemedicine, should be focussed. Finally, telemedicine should only be used where it can lead to improvement of health outcomes. For example, if the target patient population is living close to a hospital in a city, there is no cost benefit of starting telemedicine for them. It should rather be started for people living on remote mountains where transport is scarce. 
  3. Step 3: This involves ensuring that the digital environment is conducive to a telemedicine model. Both hardware and software capabilities must be checked. Not only the hardware but also the feasibility of repair and replacement must be ensured. On the software side, data security must be looked into. 
  4. Step 4: Finally, the two ends of the telemedicine model, the healthcare providers and patients, must be willing to use the service. In an overburdened LMIC hospital, a doctor may not be willing to take on the additional burden of telemedicine sessions. In many villages, there may be a single computer which everyone uses for video calls. In such cases, the patient may not be willing to use a public video call facility for intimate health issues. 

The key considerations are depicted in figure 3.

Figure 3: Main considerations for making Telemedicine successful (Goodridge et al, 201620)
 


Technology: 

Technology for telemedicine does not only include the devices required for monitoring and consultation, but also the power supply and internet services. Currently, the technology is at par with the needs for remote medical services. But for LMICs, the main consideration is cost. While the synchronous consultation via video or audio call is feasible for most, the other sophisticated devices like ICU sensors or AI-enabled hospital beds may be inaccessible for many. Many of the corporate hospitals in LMIC are now using tele-radiology through PACS, but the system is out of reach for smaller centres. 

However, many countries like India are trying to make their own lost-cost medical devices to make the technology accessible to the masses21. Such use of local technology will make telemedicine infrastructure more feasible. Digital transformation of healthcare also requires reliable power supply. While conventional grid supply of electricity is often unreliable in countries like India, this barrier can be overcome with help of renewable energy sources. For example, in the remote villages of Sundarbans, India a microgrid of solar power has been built and this has led to better use of rechargeable electronic equipment22

Legislations regarding telemedicine:

The main push for enabling legislations supporting telemedicine came after the Covid pandemic. While relevant laws were being discussed in many countries earlier, this pandemic led to quick enactment in many cases9.

Australia passed the “Telehealth Determination” legislation and officially recognized telemedicine as a channel of service delivery. Germany also passed the digital healthcare act not only to help telemedicine but also to provide guidelines for insurance. India passed the Telemedicine practice guidelines just before the national lockdown in 2020, March23. The United States of America also published the “Digital Health Implementation Playbook” to enable physicians practice Telemedicine24.  Proper legislation and government policy has helped in the integration of telemedicine in Ghana and Rwanda in public health programs. In Kenya, BYON8 is an AI-based digital physician program that is being tried for primary care25

However, in some countries, although regulations are present, they are often considered prohibitive and impractical25. One example is the telemedicine framework developed by Health Professions Council (HPCSA) of South Africa25

Thus, all concerned stakeholders including insurance providers, politicians, community workers, physicians and internet service providers must cooperate and coordinate in order to facilitate telemedicine. 

Telemedicine for special populations:

There are certain segments of the population for whom healthcare is “remote” due to other reasons.

One example is the LGBTQ people. A survey in the USA found that such sexual minorities often face multiple barriers in the health system26. These include refusal of treatment, stigma among healthcare workers and hostility from other people in a hospital. Thus, these people often avoid physical visits to healthcare facilities. In such cases, Telemedicine can be of much help in increasing their access to care. 

The second group for which digital health can be a blessing is physically challenged persons. All over the world, disabled people have significantly less access to healthcare27. In countries like India, most health centres do not have architectural modifications (like ramp or elevator) needed by disabled people to access a building. Also, other factors like cost of transportation and unsympathetic behaviour of health staff often deter these patients from going to a hospital28. In such cases, telehealth can address their unmet needs to a great extent. 

Conclusion:     

  1. Telemedicine is not meant as a replacement but rather, as complementary to traditional health care.
  2. Telemedicine is a promising tool to ensure the three principles of universal healthcare: Equity, availability and efficacy. 
  3. Implementation of effective telemedicine program requires a large-scale initial investment and in most LMICs, this will necessitate public-private partnership. 
  4. As healthcare enters into digital age, the accompanying problems like data theft, identity duplication and loss of privacy must also be addressed. Also, monopoly over health data by any single organization must be prevented. 
  5. While telemedicine is an exciting new development, it must also be ensured that it does not widen the “digital divide” further. 

References: -

  1. World Rural Population 1960-2023. Macrotrends [Online]. [Cited 2023 May 21]. Available online from https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/WLD/world/rural-population
  2. Banerjee A. Sigh of relief: Darjeeling gets its first MRI unit. MilleniumPost [Online]. [Published 2017 Apr 1; Cited 2023 May 22]. Available online from https://www.millenniumpost.in/kolkata/sigh-of-relief-darjeeling-gets-its-first-mri-unit-234455
  3. AO News Service. Poor picture as India’s doctor, patient ratio stands at 1:2000. Arunachal Observer [Online]. [Published 2017 Aug 29; Cited 2023 May 19]. Available online from https://arunachalobserver.org/2017/08/29/poor-picture-indias-doctor-patient-ratio-stands-12000/
  4. United Nations. Political Declaration of the High-level Meeting on Universal Health Coverage “Universal health coverage: moving together to build a healthier world”. [Published 2019 Sep 23]. Available online from https://www.un.org/pga/73/wp-content/uploads/sites/53/2019/07/FINAL-draft-UHC-Political-Declaration.pdf
  5. ANI. West Bengal: Unable to pay for ambulance services, man carries son's body back home in bag in North Dinajpur [Online]. Available online at https://www.aninews.in/news/national/general-news/west-bengal-unable-to-pay-for-ambulance-services-man-carries-sons-body-back-home-in-bag-in-north-dinajpur20230515090732/
  6. Nezami S. Bihar: Sitamarhi woman gives birth on road. The Times of India [Online]. [Published 2022 July 18; Cited 2023 May 20]. Available online from https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/patna/sitamarhi-womangives-birth-on-road/articleshow/92944839.cms
  7. Gaber A. Years of impact: Liberia adopts Yale capstone student recommendations for national medical education reform. Yale News [Online]. Available online from https://news.yale.edu/2018/04/30/liberia-adopts-yale-capstone-recommendations-medical-education-reform
  8. Villagers suffer lack of doctors and medicines. The New Humanitarian [Online]. [Published 2007 Mar 26; Cited 2023 May 19]. Available online from https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/report/70926/nepal-villagers-suffer-lack-doctors-and-medicines
  9. Consolidated telemedicine implementation guide. World Health Organization. Geneva: 2022
  10. ISRO Telemedicine Initiative [Internet]. Televital.com. [cited 2023 May 21]. Available from: http://www.televital.com/downloads/ISRO-Telemedicine-Initiative.pdf
  11. UCLA Mindful App. UCLA Health [Online]. Available online from https://www.uclahealth.org/programs/marc/free-programming-resources/ucla-mindful-app
  12. Mishra SK, Singh IP and Daman Chand R. Current status of telemedicine network in India and future perspective. The proceedings of the Asia-Pacific Advanced Network 2012; 32: 151-163
  13. Farzandipour M, Nabovati E, Sharif R. The effectiveness of tele-triage during the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic review and narrative synthesis. J Telemed Telecare. 2023 Jan 23 : 1357633X221150278
  14. Rathod N, Rajput A, Fouzia M, Jyothi DB, Patil K. e-ICU's/Tele ICU's, it's Role, Advantages Over Manual ICU's and Shortcomings in the Current Perspective of Covid-19 Pandemic: A Critical Review. Int J Cur Res Rev 2020; 12: 38—45
  15. Knobloch K, Rennekampff H, Vogt PM. Cell- phone based multimedia messaging service (MMS) and burn injuries. Burns. 2009;35:1191–3
  16. Tsai SH, Kraus J, Wu H, Chen W, Chiang M et al. The effectiveness of video-telemedicine for screening of patients requesting emergency air medical transport (EAMT). J Trauma. 2007;62: 504–11
  17. Hanlon P, Daines L, Campbell C, McKinstry B, Weller D, Pinnock H. Telehealth interventions to support self-management of long-term conditions: a systematic metareview of diabetes, heart failure, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and cancer. J. Med. Internet Res. 2017;19(5): e172
  18. Mann DM, Allegrante JP, Natarajan S, Halm EA, Charlson M. Predictors of adherence to statins for primary prevention. Cardiovasc. Drugs Ther. 2007;21(4):311–16
  19. Duan Y, Xie Z, Dong F, Wu Z, Lin Z, Sun N. Effectiveness of home blood pressure telemonitoring: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled studies. J. Hum. Hypertens. 2017;31(7):427–37
  20. Goodridge D, Marciniuk D. Rural and remote care: Overcoming the challenges of distance. Chron Respir Dis. 2016; 13(2): 192–203
  21. IIT-B develops low-cost sensors to detect pulse rate variability. Biospectrum [Online]. [Published 2021 Aug 13; Cited 2023 May 20]]. Available online from https://www.biospectrumindia.com/news/58/19362/iit-b-develops-low-cost-sensors-to-detect-pulse-rate-variability.html
  22. Solar Microgrid - Sundarbans, West Bengal, India - 110 KW. Tata Power. Available online from https://www.tatapower.com/plants-projects/microgrids/110-kw-solar-microgrid-sundarbans-west-bengal-india.aspx
  23. Telemedicine Practice Guidelines: Enabling Registered Medical Practitioners to Provide Healthcare Using Telemedicine. Medical Council of India. Available online from https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/Telemedicine.pdf
  24. Telehealth implementation Playbook. The American Medical Association, 2022. [Cited 2023 May 23]. Available online from https://www.ama-assn.org/system/files/ama-telehealth-playbook.pdf
  25. Percept Actuaries and Consultants, and Cenfri. Kellett J (Ed.). Insurance and Telemedicine in Africa. UNDP. [Cited 2023 May 22]. Available online from https://irff.undp.org/sites/default/files/2022-10/insurance-and-telemedicine-in-africa-moonshot.pdf
  26. Clift JB, Kirby J. Health care access and perceptions of provider care among individuals in same-sex couples: findings from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) J Homosex. 2012;59(6):839–50
  27. Sommers AS. Access to health insurance, barriers to care, and service use among adults with disabilities. Inquiry. 2008, 43: 393-405
  28. Ahmad M. Health care access and barriers for the physically disabled in rural Punjab, Pakistan. Int. J. Sociol. Soc. Pol. 2013; 33:246–60
     
Rudrajit Paul

Dr Rudrajit Paul is a consultant Physician at Ruby General Hospital, Kolkata. A former medical professor and HIV master trainer of NACO, he is keenly interested in clinical research and has published numerous articles in indexed international journals. His research interests include climate change and human health, infectious diseases etc.

Meera Suresh

Dr Meera Suresh is an Associate Professor in the Department of Homeopathy at Lincoln University College, Malaysia. She was also the Program Manager of KDPP-WDF project at SCTIMST which was aimed to reduce Diabetes incidence in Kerala. She is a Homeopathic physician with interest in public health research.

Harvard Medical School - Leadership in Medicine Southeast Asia47th IHF World Hospital Congress